4 star red heroes that aren’t worth keeping

[Piro]

Hi,I am not a collector and I would like to keep only useful heroes. I have many red 4* heroes already ascended and few unleveled. I would like to hear your opinion who is worth keeping and who should become food.

I have:
a) fully ascended with emblems and LB:

• Boldtusk(with costume)
• Ferant
• Gormek(with costume)
• Aodhan
• Eichbelborg
• Carol
• Wilbur (with costume)
• Guardian Falcon

b) fully ascended

• Sumle(with costume)
• Second Boldtusk
• Sir Lancelot

c) unleveled

• Maheegan
• Mack
• Lemminkäinen
• Zhabog
• Cillian
• Shale
• Shadereave
• Second Wilbur

Who is worth keeping?

• Maheegan
• Mack
• Lemminkäinen
• Zhabog
• Cillian
• Shale
• Shadereave
• Second Wilbur

Who should I get rid of?

• Maheegan
• Mack
• Lemminkäinen
• Zhabog
• Cillian
• Shale
• Shadereave
• Second Wilbur
• all are worth keepeing

Thanks in advance for answering and voting. Good luck and good battles.

[sylvelliorFD]

Maheegan is worth the LB

[mogulemon]

Get rid shadereave and shale. They are trash

[Tidyup]

Lemminkainen, trash hero. Even colen is better

[Gargon]

The only two of those I have maxed (and don´t regret) are Cillian (good overall hero and will have family bonus with Aodhan!) and Zhabog (Bard to speed up others).

None of the others are important, but Shadereave can have a niche use against titans (I keep one unlevelled until I get really bored lol). A second Wilbur costume can be useful for Mythic titans.
All others are useless. Just didn´t have enough votes to vote them all out

[Gimliv]

2nd Wilbur is only worth keeping if you focus on Mythic titan.

Happy gaming

[ahbombim]

Nothing to advise before costumes had appeared.

To Wilbur, I’m keep 1 ori and 1 costume, with each talent fixed in.

[The_Seeker]

Wilbur (defence down) + Wilbur costume (super-attack) can be good together against titans if you don’t have other better options.

Cillian is really great (and I don’t even lb him yet) and Zhabog with the right troops can really make a difference with the bard bonus (my Xnolphod and Ludwig team is working again)

[Kith]

I would recommend you to keep at least one copy of each hero. You never know , that hero may get a boost in the future.

[rebelsouljah]

Haha!! Just like the Skittle and the Cyprian that I got when I first started, but then was not impressed by them so I let them be eaten by a new 5*, but now those two have pretty awesome second costumes.

But yeah, keep Maheegan, Zhabog and maybe even Cillian. Mack was impressive, and then Ferant came along. Shadereave is good only for the crit hit, but otherwise forgettable. A duplicate Wilbur is only if you need war depth, and even that is getting desperate. One is enough.

[Piro]

Thanks for answering, voting and advices. I will get rid of Mack, Shadereave and Shale. Rest can stay, for now…

[Maximo101]

Zhabog is good in my opinion(but i dont have much of a roster compared to you), 5% mana for bard family bonus, reduces revive % of enemy and special resets enemy’s ailments.
I dont have a massive roster but he pairs well for war teams where i want to keep resetting certain ailments,