As per the letter of that question, I have done it. I have no HotM. My only event hero is Vlad. 
As yet unlevelled, and unlikely to ever face Guin.
But I donāt think Iāve ever beaten a maxed Guin with a proper (4000+ power) team. Or at least, not outside of the event (where I can use items).
I might give it a try one of these days.
I donāt think a regular team can beat a team with Guin that has HOTM and event heroes in it, the game is for paying players , if your regular heroes can beat a specialise team, then why bother spending money to summons. If any can please post vids.
I suggest you watch this:
Yes, that was my question at the start of this thread. Iām fine with ājust beating Guinā since so many war opponents use her as a tank. Cleanup can get the rest. 
Iāve beaten Guin multiple times with Gravemaker being my only 5*. Iāve beaten some really strong teams and Iāve lost to lower teams I shouldāve beat. Itās all about the board and strategy used. You win some you lose some. Sheās not unbeatable but it seems thatās everyoneās mentality I donāt get it.
Yes beatable, you did admit that you had favourable board. I must admit it can be done thanks Zero.
Fully admit that. And right after i posted this i lost 3 in a row against another Guin tank lol. Though that was with my actual anti Guin team, not an F2P friendly team. Just goes to show that she is merciless regardless of heroes you bring against her. But she is beatable.
Even the best player in the game need a bit of luck. Suppose itās like fishing, you only tell your friends the day when you went out and caught a bunch of fish. You donāt tell people you spent the whole day fishing and catch nothing but a cold.
The team I use to beat high rankers with Guin are as below:
Sartana
Rigard
Tibertus
Grimm
Kiril
So yes you can beat with a regular team.
Sometimes I do switch Kiril or Rigard with Alasie
Yet he just did: 
Let me put it as it follows, if I want to lose cups, I put Guin in my defense team as a tank Really, Iām not joking, with her there Iām attacked much more and fail to repel attacks of much weaker teams. Alasie, on the other hand, holds cups quite well.
@Argon, who were your flanks because Guin isnāt the issue for most people. The problems are the two heroes on her flanks. If you have Guin in center but you have crap heroes flanking her, then she really canāt help much.
I tried Drake-GM-Guin-Alasie-Sartana or Sartana-GM-Guin-Alasie-Marjana and lost about 200 cups over night, usually 40+ 
@Argon, I see your problem. You have people that can easily stack against you because you donāt have two purple and you donāt have another healer other than Guin. If you have a Khiona or Aegir, I suggest leveling them. If you have the capability, try and pull a green 5* when you get your next nature element summon. With Guin Kadelin as a flank becomes very useful and sheās the best normal 5* you can have paired with Guin.
I donāt have any of those heroes, but to not to stray from original post, I can confirm as Guin owner if you donāt have right heroes to accompany Guin in raid defense team, sheās quite easily beatable without need of strong team.
Very much doable. But if the boards are against you nothing can be done about it. Guin punishes bad boards. Against the above was one good and one bad board. Hence the win and loss.
Without Zeline to lower the ATK of the whole team you can consider swapping Sartana from the corner to a flank (Gravemaker is better on the left flank, so to the right one) as many attackers will stack purple when attacking Guinevere and doing so your right flank will take longer to collapse.
Are season 2 heroes allowed? I use ghost girl protious Obakan then Wilbur usually with Gravemaker but since heās disqualified I can put Azlar in there but my preferred team is Khoina protious ghost girl Gravemaker Wilbur and as long as I get a decent board I can win even when they have 2 Gravemaker and 2 hel flanking her
src=āYouTubeā width=ā480ā height=ā360ā frameborder=ā0ā
I only see one mistake in that video. When Boldtusk and Rigard were both powered up, you were saving one for Zeline because there was a chance her special was going to fire. You should have used Rigard first and countered with Boldtusk instead of the other way around. After that set of moves you still would have an attack buff coming out of it.
Yes, S2 regular heroes can be used here (though the thread was made for S1 regular heroes originally.)
No HOTM or event heroes, please.
