Poll For Best 4 ⭐ Heroes By Colour [as of Feb 2024]

Gameplay Help & Tactics
, , , ,
1

2nd edition of Poll for Best 4 Star Heroes by Colour. Full history behind poll, view 1st edition here: https://forum.smallgiantgames.com/t/poll-for-best-4-heroes-by-colour-2021-2022

Some heroes have been excluded from the poll (fared worse in previous poll) as poll can only have up to 20 options.

Time to vote for your MVPs! :smiley:

Fire (:red_square:) 4 :star: Hero - Pick up to 5
Excluded heroes: Aodhan, Carol, Eichelborg, Gormek, Maheegan, Rokkamush, Shale, Shadereave & Sumitomo

  • Boldtusk
  • Cilian
  • Colen
  • Ferant
  • Guardian Falcon
  • Itham
  • Junaid
  • Kellie
  • Lemminkäinen
  • Lucy
  • Mack
  • Nova
  • Raul
  • Scarlett
  • Sir Lancelot
  • Sumle
  • Sun Shangxiang
  • Wilbur
  • Zhabog
  • Zhou Yu
0 voters

Costumed Fire (:red_square:) 4 :star: Hero - Pick up to 5

  • Boldtusk (War Feast)
  • Boldtusk (War Song)
  • Boldtusk (Tooncry)
  • Colen (Flame Assault)
  • Colen (Flame Storm)
  • Colen (Toon Storm)
  • Gormek (Pulverizing Abacus)
  • Gormek (Pulverizing Ham)
  • Kellie (Dance of Ignition)
  • Kellie (Dance of Flame)
  • Scarlett (Blades of Venom)
  • Scarlett (Blades on the Dance Floor)
  • Sumitomo
  • Sumle
  • Wilbur
0 voters

Ice (:blue_square:) 4 :star: Hero - Pick up to 5
Excluded heroes: Agwe, Captain of Diamonds, Mireweavee & Valeria

  • Aqualith
  • Azmia
  • Boril
  • Fosco
  • Frank
  • Garyas
  • Grimm
  • Jott
  • Kiril
  • Knucles
  • Linus
  • Olbec
  • Sanngrior
  • Sapphire
  • Sonya
  • Triton
  • Xiahou Dun
  • Zila Lei
0 voters

Costumed Ice (:blue_square:) 4 :star: Hero - Pick up to 5

  • Agwe
  • Boril (Sturdy Riposte)
  • Boril (Unrelenting Riposte)
  • Frank
  • Grimm (Merciless Pulverizer)
  • Grimm (Postal Pulverizer)
  • Grimm (Toonpower Pulverizer)
  • Kiril (Blessed Solo)
  • Kiril (Blessed Tankard)
  • Kiril (Toon Brew)
  • Sonya (Purifying Strike)
  • Sonya (Wrenching Strike)
  • Triton
  • Zila Lei
0 voters

Holy (:yellow_square:) 4 :star: Hero - Pick up to 5
Excluded heroes: Chao, Danzaburo & Gretel

  • Anastasia
  • Bellerive
  • Bogart
  • D’Andre
  • Goldie
  • Griffin
  • Guardian Jackal
  • Gullinbursti
  • Holly
  • Hu Tao
  • Lady Woolerton
  • Li Xiu
  • Mist
  • Scoratek
  • Steropes
  • Voluptas
  • Waddles
  • Wang Yuanji
  • Wu Kong
  • Zione
0 voters

Costumed Holy (:yellow_square:) 4 :star: Hero - Pick up to 5

  • Chao (Ornithological Cut)
  • Chao (Cub Leader Cut)
  • Danzaburo
  • Griffin
  • Guardian Jackal
  • Gullinbursti
  • Hu Tao (Aura Wave)
  • Hu Tao (Acoustic Surge)
  • Li Xiu (Slash of Seven Daggers)
  • Li Xiu (Slash of th)e Seven Stilettos)
  • Wu Kong (Gambler’s Slash
  • Wu Kong (Gambler’s Swing)
0 voters

Nature (:green_square:) 4 :star: Hero - Pick up to 5
Excluded heroes: Anton, Gobbler, Jack O’Hare, Little John, Kale, Orla & Wren

  • Alfie
  • Almur
  • Brontes
  • Brynhild
  • Buddy
  • Caedmon
  • Franz
  • Hansel
  • Kashhrek
  • Lionstring
  • Marcel
  • Melendor
  • Mielikki
  • Mulgog
  • Numbskull
  • Peters
  • Ptolemy
  • Raleigh
  • Tettukh
  • Villiers
0 voters

Costumed Nature (Green) 4 :star: Hero - Pick up to 5
Excluded heroes: Skittleskull first costume

  • Almur
  • Caedmon (Cleansing Strike)
  • Caedmon (Valorant Strike)
  • Caedmon (Toontastic Strike)
  • Gadeirus
  • Gobbler
  • Hansel
  • Jack O’Hare
  • Kashhrek (Second Skin)
  • Kashhrek (Scaly Skin)
  • Little John (Massive Cleave)
  • Little John (Massive Swing)
  • Melendor (Fog of the Perished)
  • Melendor (Fog of the Smoke Machine)
  • Melendor (Toontastic Fog)
  • Mielikki
  • Peters
  • Skittleskull (Crawling Vines)
  • Skittleskull (Toon Vines)
  • Tettukh
0 voters

Dark (:purple_square:) 4 :star: Hero - Pick up to 5
*Excluded heroes: Ameonna, Boomer, Cheshire Cat, Cyprian, Fura, Gafar, Ingolf, Jabbar & Merlin

  • Ahhotep
  • Ametrine
  • Ana-Belle
  • Arges
  • Cupcake
  • Dizzy
  • Heifeng Guai
  • Ingolf
  • Juliani
  • Kitty
  • Koda
  • Lexi
  • Meadow
  • Proteus
  • Rigard
  • Sabina
  • Sergei
  • Shar’Khai
  • Stonecleave
  • Tiburtus
0 voters

Costumed Dark (:purple_square:) 4 :star: Hero - Pick up to 5

  • Ameonna
  • Cheshire Cat
  • Cyprian (Deadly Riposte)
  • Cyprian (Precise Riposte)
  • Fura
  • Merlin
  • Proteus
  • Rigard (Regeneration)
  • Rigard (Transfigure)
  • Sabina (Haze of the Fallen)
  • Sabina (Mist of the Fallen)
  • Tiburtus (Symphonic Pulverizer)
  • Tiburtus (Elegant Pulverizer)
0 voters

Poll for Best 3 :star: Heroes By Colour [2023]

8 Likes
2

Very good initiative, I am very curious to see the results :+1: :ok_hand:

1 Like
3

I voted.

My 4* i bring along also in many 5* battles are Goldie en Shar’khai. Also other but those are just the best imho. They deserve 3 votes :yum:

2 Likes
4

I love these sorts of polls! thank you very much for creating this!

3 Likes
5

Great post. One important note: You may have forgotten the best 4 star of all and that’s Kitty.

1 Like
6

know you had limited choices but wish kalo was an option for green

2 Likes
7

Thanks @bamboosymphony for adding her!

1 Like
8

Yep, i have him 2lb and use him in rush all the time, holds up even against 5*

9

I still need to get all the 4* S1 costumes available. Rigard, in particular, is probably the ONLY hero I have so far that hasn’t gotten ANY of the costumes and it’s irritating me because he’s the main one I’ve been chasing for since the first costume for him dropped.

Maybe I’ll get lucky when they release Toon Rigard, with something like:

  • Recovers 40% health
  • All allies get +30% attack; undispellable and 2 turns longer for Dark. AND/OR +30% defense
  • Cleanse status ailments from all allies.

Similarly, if they ever let the other events play out, a bunch of these 4* heroes I kinda wish I had in my roster, even if I didn’t use them much or as much as my current roster of 4* heroes.

1 Like
10

I dont expect both attack and defense and if they do not with those numbers. Else he would eclipse all other toon healers by a wide margin.

I havent got any Melendor costumes over all these years. So sometimes the chances in this game are just almost impossible :slight_smile:

1 Like
11

Can results be seen without having to vote ? Any newer players who will be the ones most interested in results will have to vote on heros they no nothing about to see results. Totally screwing it up.

4 Likes
12

Great poll, thanks! It will help ppl sort out their roasters and get rid of some of the heroes to make room for feeders.

1 Like
13

Thank you for asking, it shows you actually have a lot of sense :slight_smile:
But don´t worry those polls are always 50% nonsense anyway, people will vote for completely different things, some go by who they have, some by who they would like to have or pick the newest hero or whatever´s the fashion at the time of the poll. Some vote by actual quality, while some just vote by the artwork, click something randomly, or whatever is first in the list just to see the results.
If you get enough responses the hope is to be able to dismiss the random nonsense, while various of the above options hopefully point to a somewhat higher quality of a hero. but in the end those polls are mostly for entertainment and hopefully don´t put the worst ones up top.
So long answer short go vote for the one you like best for whatever reason and then have fun looking at what others like, just don´t necessarily max you heroes in order of the poll :wink:

14

I figured +30% because it seems like a recurring thing I’ve noticed with every new hero that does +atk% or +def% that isn’t event-specific. Plus, by itself, Rigard only cleanses and heals. I wouldn’t know if they’d modify something for Dark allies or something for Holy enemies.

Let’s hope for +atk% for Rigard because Melendor already has +def%. Or +mana gen%!

15

Hey there, reason why you have to vote before seeing results is to reduce the chances of people choosing just because many people choose the hero. If you are a newer player, recommendation is to accumulate as many different 4* heroes as possible and only use the poll to guide you on who to max/which dupes to keep. Can’t edit the poll at this time tho as everything would get reset