Worst 5* In Every Color of Each Season

As the title says, I want y’all to tell me who you think the worst heroes in each color are from every season.

Season 1:

•Green- Elkanen
•Yellow- Justice
•Blue- Thorne
•Purple- Obakan
•Red- khagan

Season 2:

•Green- Atomos
•Yellow- Inari
•Blue- Misandra
•Purple- Mok-Arr
•Red- Mitsuko

Season 3:

•Green- Heimdall
•Yellow- Thor
•Blue- Fenrir
•Purple- Salmon Loki
•Red- Baldur

Season 4:

•Green- Garjammal
•Yellow- Akkarog
•Blue- Exeera
•Purple- Dr. Moreu (this was a difficult choice)
•Red- Kravekrush (the one that stops revivers)

Season 5:

•Green- Ma’at (greens are the most balanced for this season)
•Yellow- Papyros
•Blue- Bennu
•Purple- Set
•Red- Sekhmet

What do you think of this list? What about your lists?

9 Likes

I can only definitively speak from experience for S1. I only have one hero each from S2 and S3, and none from the others.

S1:

Purple - Quintus
This is a tough one between him and Obakan but I never even maxed Quintus until I got the costume.

Yellow - Leonidas
I use Justice on my defense. I rarely used Leo until costume.

Blue - Thorne
I always chose Richard over him

Green - Horghall
A poor attempt at a beefy tank that hits like paper and only has a lot of health going for him. I do actually use Elkanan.

Red - Khagan
I always chose Azlar over him.

6 Likes

What a fun idea! You definitely hit the spot on some of them and suprised me with others ^^.

I’ll take it a step further and list my best and worst for most of the portals I can think of! Keep in mind these are my personal opinions!

Also if a hero is considered the worst of a specific portal it does not always mean it is a bad hero! Some portals are just filled with a lot of amazing heroes and even the worst one is very good :slight_smile: .

(Some portals and heroes are missing since there are so few heroes of that portal.)

Season 1:

Best & Worst

Best(no costumes):
:purple_circle: Domitia
:yellow_circle: Vivica
:large_blue_circle: Magni
:green_circle: Lianna
:red_circle: Khagan

Worst(no costumes):
:purple_circle: Obakan
:yellow_circle: Justice
:large_blue_circle: Thorne
:green_circle: Horghall without maxed Talents, other wise Elkanen
:red_circle: Azlar

Season 2:

Best & Worst

Best:
:purple_circle: Costume Kageburado
:yellow_circle: Costume Poseidon
:large_blue_circle: Costume Ariel (closely followed by Tethys)
:green_circle: Tarlak
:red_circle: Oceanus

Worst:
:purple_circle: Mok-Arr
:yellow_circle: Costume Inari
:large_blue_circle: Misandra
:green_circle: Atomos (My first green hero :frowning: )
:red_circle: Mitsuko (I don’t think she’s bad at all, she’s just the only red 5* hero left)

Season 3:

Best & Worst

Best:
:purple_circle: Costume Freya (Closely followed by Alfrike)
:yellow_circle: Costume Sif
:large_blue_circle: Lord Loki on high trophies, Skadi on low trophies
:green_circle: Costume Heimdall
:red_circle: Costume Gefjon

Worst:
:purple_circle: Salmon Loki (Which is too bad, I like his animation :slight_smile: )
:yellow_circle: Thor
:large_blue_circle: Fenrir
:green_circle: Heimdall
:red_circle: Baldur

Season 4:

Best & Worst

Best:
:purple_circle: Hulda
:yellow_circle: Prof. Lidenbrock
:large_blue_circle: Morel
:green_circle: Phíleas Fogg
:red_circle: Octros

Worst:
:purple_circle: Lepiota
:yellow_circle: Aouda
:large_blue_circle: Exeera (Shocker! I know :stuck_out_tongue: )
:green_circle: Garjammal
:red_circle: Captain Nemo

Season 5:

Best & Worst

Best:
:purple_circle: Bastet
:yellow_circle: Cleopatra
:large_blue_circle: Sobek
:green_circle: El Naddaha
:red_circle: Khufu (Extremely closely followed by Hathor)

Worst:
:purple_circle: Set
:yellow_circle: Papyros
:large_blue_circle: Bennu (only blue besides Sobek)
:green_circle: Ahmose
:red_circle: Sekhmet (Wauw Dunes has some good 5* reds that Sekhmet is the weakest of the 3)

Seasonal heroes (all seasonals)

Best & Worst

Best:
:purple_circle: Louhi
:yellow_circle: Matilda
:large_blue_circle: Miriam & Midnight
:green_circle: Costume Mother North
:red_circle: Alucard

Worst:
:purple_circle: Victor
:yellow_circle: Roc
:large_blue_circle: Master Lepus
:green_circle: Yunan
:red_circle: Santa Claus

Heroes of the Month:

Best & Worst

Best:
:purple_circle: Costume Hel
:yellow_circle: Devana (Closely followed by Malosi)
:large_blue_circle: Costume Perseus
:green_circle: Evelynn
:red_circle: Zimkitha

Worst:
:purple_circle: Zulag
:yellow_circle: Ranvir
:large_blue_circle: Klaern
:green_circle: Telluria
:red_circle: Ares

War of Three Kingdoms:

Best & Worst

Best:
:purple_circle: Diaochan
:yellow_circle: Zhang Fei
:large_blue_circle: Cao Cao
:green_circle: Guan Yu
:red_circle: Sun Quan

Worst:
:purple_circle: Lu Bu
:yellow_circle: Zhuge Liang
:large_blue_circle: Cao Cao
:green_circle: Liu Bei
:red_circle: Sun Quan

Tower heroes:

Best & Worst

Best:
:purple_circle: Nyx
:yellow_circle: Nemesis
:large_blue_circle: Milena
:green_circle: Peridot
:red_circle: Erebus

Worst:
:purple_circle: Quartz
:yellow_circle: Mica
:large_blue_circle: Zircon
:green_circle: Cristóbal
:red_circle: Nadezhda

Challenge event heroes:

Best & Worst

Best:
:purple_circle: Costume Guardian Panther (Wow what a suprise!)
:yellow_circle: Anne
:large_blue_circle: Bubbles
:green_circle: Toxicandra
:red_circle: Costume Guardian Kong

Worst:
:purple_circle: Boss Wolf
:yellow_circle: Guinevere or Guardian Owl (Guardian Owl is still my favourite hero in the game, please SG give me a reason to limit break him :frowning: )
:large_blue_circle: Rian
:green_circle: Morgan Le Fay
:red_circle: Captain Krestel

Alliance Quest (Raven, Wolf and Musketeer families):

Best & Worst

Best:
:purple_circle: Ludwig
:yellow_circle: Eloise
:large_blue_circle: Quintin
:green_circle: Quenell
:red_circle: D’Artagnan

Worst:
:purple_circle: Rayne
:yellow_circle: Wolfgang
:large_blue_circle: Porthos
:green_circle: Queen Anne
:red_circle: Lewena

Costume Chamber:

Best & Worst

Best:
:purple_circle: C2Domitia
:yellow_circle: C1Leonidas
:large_blue_circle: C2Magni
:green_circle: C1Kadilen
:red_circle: C1Marjana

Worst:
:purple_circle: C1Quintus
:yellow_circle: C1Justice
:large_blue_circle: C1Richard
:green_circle: C1Horghall
:red_circle: C1Elena

7 Likes

Interesting that you find Erebus a better red tower hero than Garnet & Ruby. Erebus seems to get nothing but hate and i know lots that have left him at 1.1. While the red ninjas are still loved to this day even while being older heros

3 Likes

The interesting thing about this list is what was good back then versus now. Guinevere was at the top of the game at one time. Inari was pretty bad but with the buff, much better. Obakan wasn’t considered good until the second costume.

1 Like

Same, except I have two S2 5*s. but definitely not experience to say.

  1. Purple - Obakan,. Quintus gets some use in Rush and Tower events, and I would pick Quintus over Obakan most days. (have neither costume)

  2. Yellow - this is a tough one, and in fact Justice, but it was close. Justice gets use in Rush and Tower events. But once I got my Yellow mana troop to 23, Leonidas started getting more use in War and Tower events too. Leo’s mana cut is also a bit more unique than Justice’s blind (considering I also have Joon).

  3. Blue - definitely Thorne. partly because he’s not levelled yet, and I don’t have his costume… I’m not sure how the costume would change things though. I do have Richard’s costume. and I do think Richard’s attack debuff is more useful than base Thorne’s pure damage in most cases

  4. Green - Elkanen. Horghall at least has a niche in Rush, and his attack debuff helps the team survive in PvE. Kadilen also helps with survival. Elkanen struggles to find a place in my roster as he doesn’t really help the team’s overall survivability

  5. Red - also a very tough one. I love Khagan’s mana boost (and I do have his costume too), so not Khagan. Elena used to get a lot of use, but Ferant has displaced her as my Red riposter of choice. Azlar is just Azlar. I’d say overall Azlar, because Elena’s riposte still comes in handy in PvE (especially Tower events) in cases where I can’t use Ferant, whereas Azlar’s burn damage is less useful in higher Tower floors.

4 Likes

Always interesting how different players find uses for different heroes :+1:

3 Likes

S1:
*Dark:Obakan
*Holy:Justice
*Nature:Elkanen
*Ice:Richard (I like Thorne)
*Fire:Azlar?
To be honest, Khagan is very useful hero in AQ, challenges, events…
S2:

  • Dark:hard choice but without costume I would say Ursena, she did not kick hard
    *Holy:Inari without costume
    *Nature:Atomos
    *Ice:Misandra
    *Fire:Well this is not a nice deal because Mitsuko is not bad at all.
    S3:
    *Dark:Salmon Loki
    *Holy:Thor
    *Nature:hard choice but lets go with Heimdall because MN is much more used in vf wars then him
    *Ice:Fenrir
    *Fire:Tyr
    S4:
    *Dark:Dr. Moreu
    *Holy : Aouda even that I think that she is great hero
    *Nature:Lughadi
    *ice:Exeera
    *Fire:C. Nemo
    S5:
    *Dark:Set
    *Holy:Papyrus
    *Nature:agggh they are all sooooo good.
    *Ice:Bennu but he is not that bad
    *Fire :Sekhmet, I mean Tetisheri and Khufu are waaaay more better hero then her. Sorry

My favorite heroes from every season are:
S1:
*Dark :Sartana C
*Holy:Leonidas C
*Nature:Kadilen C
*Ice:Magni CC
*Fire:one and only Marjana C
S2:
*Dark :Kageburado
*Holy :Inari C
*Nature:Tarlak
*Ice:Tethys
*Fire:Oceanus
S3:
*Dark:Alfrike
*Holy:Odin
*Nature:Ratatoskr
*Ice:Skadi C
*Fire:Gefjon C
S4:
*Dark:Xnol, well he is amazing healer
*Holy:Prof.
*Nature:Garjammal, I just like her a lot
*Ice:Morel
*Fire:Zenobia
S5:
*Dark :Bastet/Khepri
*Holy:Cleopatra
*Nature:Maat
*Ice:Sobek
*Fire:Hathor /Tetisheri

3 Likes

S1
Yellow - Justice - never maxed my only copy
Purple - Quintus - never maxed my only copy
Green - Horghall - I did get his first costume, but his usage didn’t last long, I’m not even using him in rush anymore.
Red - Hard… either Azlar or Elena, choosing Elena as I use Ferant as my red riposte.
Blue - Thorne - never maxed my only copy

S2 -
Yellow - Poseidon
Purple - Mok-Arr
Green - Atomos
Red - No one, I love my Mitsuko, I bet Oceanus is good too, though he was released much later
Blue - Misandra

S3
Yellow - Thor
Purple - Salmon Loki
Green - Idk, Heimdall and Rata are both ok healers, can’t choose here.
Red - Tyr/Baldur, can’t choose
Blue - Fenrir

S4 -
Yellow - Aouda/Akkorog, can’t choose honestly
Purple - after Xnol nerf probably Xnol
Green - Lughaid or what’s his name
Red - Captain Nemo
Blue - Exeera

S5 -
Yellow - Papyros - I use him all the time, cause I don’t have a similar minion summoner, but I can see many people rendering him useless, becase they got better minion summoners.
Purple - Set
Green - none, I think they are all good
Red - Sekhmet
Blue - none, I think Bennu and Sobek are both good.

This is all just from top of my head, there are so many goddamn heroes in this game, that I just can’t remember everyone anymore…

2 Likes

I wouldn’t call any hero bad. Each has a different special attack, so they have a different meaning in right used :laughing:

Maybe just less use and happy new year! :sparkler::sparkler:

3 Likes

You never met Exeera, then!

Btw, out of ten replies, nine said Exeera

4 Likes

I’m surprised! I actually prefer Elkanen to Kadilen. For me it’s usually all about how quickly you can take down a targeted hero and kadilen doesn’t do much damage, and her s def up doesn’t do much for me either. I’ve had a few close calls with Elkanen who managed to close out a few war raids lol

That said they are both relatively bad imho lol

1 Like

I know my choice of Kadilen > Elkanen is colored (heh pun intended) by where I use them. I wouldn’t use either for Wars, generally, as I have better Green options. But I do use both for PvE depth e.g. in Towers or Elemental Quest… and Kadilen generally seems more useful to me because she helps the entire team stay alive longer. :slight_smile:

agree that both are relatively bad though :stuck_out_tongue:

1 Like

They both are absolutely bad, not relatively

Actually, it is very relative…to one’s roster choices. But yea, if you have anything else, it’s probably better.

Bende khaganı sevmiyorum azlar tercih edrdim.

Why all the Fenrir hate?

He’s been my limit-broken, emblemed tank for a long time, and he’s a beast. Best finisher in the game in my experience.

And Heimdall made this list?

1 Like

Right!? I love Fenrir and Heimdall… And Tyr! He’s done great work for me. And Baldur is amazing with all the LotL and Waterpipes running around.

Just one gamer’s opinion

Game Well :sunglasses: :mechanical_arm: :wolf:

1 Like

Well, if you have to pick one “worst” from each season in each element and the season has 3-5 heroes in that element, it might be that there are no actual bad heroes from that particular element from that particular season :slight_smile:

Personally I agree that Gefjon and Lady Loki have more uses than Tyr and Baldur. And that Fenrir is not as good as Skadi or Lord Loki.

3 Likes