Which hero is best in no red 3* tournament?

[Blord]

I got By-Ulf first of this trio. Then Grevle and a last Scrubbear joins in. In a no red 3* tournament which green hero is usefull in defense ? By-ulf is Paladin, very usefull as tank but his defense is low. Even after some emblems. Grevle has a great defense stat but his heath is low. I don’t know where Scrubbear fits in. I think grevle is the best of this trio but others may chims in.
My other rare greens are Belith, Mnesseus, Hisan, costume Isshtak with his defense down.

[BubblesUK]

I don’t rate By-Ulf particularly highly… He’s massively outclassed in this company.

Grevle and Shrubbear are both excellent - I have both maxed and emblemed and both get used plenty!

For obvious reasons, Grevle sucks on bloody battle tournaments, but he’s god tier on rush attack and better than the Shrub on buff booster.

[Guvnor]

Agreed with @BubblesUK; I also don’t rate By-Ulf virtually at all… I levelled him thinking he’d be awesome for tournaments but really don’t use him ever…

My thoughts are more here:

@B1gHeadAss

@ZyzzyxRoad @Guvnor How come you guys don’t like By-Ulf? I have By-Ulf, Grevle and Shrubbear and I find that By-Ulf is better at tanking than either of them for Buff booster no red (and possibly rush attack). I usually flank with Gato to prevent the status ailments.

@Guvnor

Because of the negative side effects… Sure gato COULD block them but isn’t guaranteed on defence…
Plus there are other options who can do the buff-boosting just as well in terms of the total # of buffs, or more, (e.g. costume belith or any other hero who does +2 buffs to all allies) who DON’T have the negative side-effect.

Defence I don’t need that kind of thing. My defences still get A grade. The one time I DID tank him with gato flanks it ended up with a D grade so… no bono there.

In Offence I have tried using him and just get annoyed… Having tho hold back his stuff so I can have Gato Ready to go just annoys me. Or relying on “refiring” specials is just an unnecessary gamble. Then in terms of his “buffs” I refer to above where there are other heroes who don’t have the negative effect & still have the same number of buffs or better synergies without the negative effects.

Shrubbear I have said many times is a better flank than a Tank but has the versatility to do both. By-Ulf doesn’t. Plus he has no draw-backs, unlike By-Ulf.

Grevle does a full team attack boost AND health boost. Pair him with another healer and you can easily negate any incoming damage you would be recieving & build up a buffer. Plus affects the entire team & has no negative side effects… Unlike By-Ulf.

TLDR is that I dislike the “negative” effect & can do as well or better without him. I levelled By-Ulf and had high initial hopes for him (like you still do) but now never use him. Ever.

@B1gHeadAss

I find the positive effects far outweight the negative side effects since the negatives only affect By-Ulf. Usually I only need to fire By-Ulf once to decide the outcome of the match. On defense, I think By-Ulf firing once is also enough to stay alive buy time for flanks. I do agree that Grevle is probably an overall better offensive hero.

@Guvnor

Yeah but if you can do without the negatives its still better It’s not a case of “negatives are outweighed by his benefits”. For me its:

• Hero A (e.g. Hawkmoon costume = 10 buffs inc. Attack Buff; Grevle + Costume Belith = 15 buffs undispellable) – Basically achieves the same (or IMO better) WITHOUT negatives

vs.

• Hero B (By-Ulf = 9 buffs) who does the same WITH negatives.

Hence I don’t bother with By-Ulf. Not because I don’t think that the “positives are outweighed by the negatives”; but purely because I think that there are better options than By-Ulf, even if he didn’t have the negatives

But yes, I personally think Shrubbear is one of the nastiest Flanks in the Game…
His special is a defence buff & taunt. Meaning he needs to be alive when the enemy special skills fire off. In the Tank position, this isn’t a guarantee as the tank bears the brunt of all tile damage. In flank, he is protected and is far far far more likely to be alive in time to fire his special while having enough tiles & to block the enemy special skills.
So if you can prop him in behind a tank who’ll buy you time (e.g. a mana cutter like Bauchan or an annoyance like Gill-Ra) he will really shine.

[DaveCozy]

By-Ulf is a staple in my green Challenge Event team (cBrienne, Ishhtak, By-Ulf, Mnesseus, Berden) but I’m not particularly fond of him for defense. I had him emblemed at one point to +20 but after 3 tournaments of D, C and C ranks I didn’t feel like being the guinea pig any longer to keep gauging his potential. I’ve stripped him since in favor of better paladin 3* (Tyrum, Gunnar and Ei-Dunn come to mind).

For Shrubear he can be very tough to take down after the fires but he is also dispelled easily by Mnesseus and Tyrum. Personally I think he’s a much better offensive 3* and only wish I had him for that.

Grevle is only one out of those that has given me significant trouble in recent 3* tournaments where healing is allowed. He’s basically a mini Heimdall without the resurrection, his defense stat is the highest in 3* rarity and his boosted HP makes him much more difficult to take out than he seems. He’s the one I’d choose to use on a 3* defense team out of those green heroes.

[Rduke77]

By-Ulf got me an A in a few buff booster tourneys…but then Grevle came out. By-Ulf was put out to pasture by Grevle.

[ZyzzyxRoad]

Grevle is best. Bi-Ulf is sub-par & only heals/shields 3. Burns bright then crashes if you haven’t won. No such shortcoming w Grevle or Shrubbear. But, I also have left my BiUlf at 1/1 so maybe consider the input from those who’ve used him.