USD Offers, Screenshots, Valuations & Discussions

Even worse … then my estimated price is 5 eurs higher :slight_smile:

1 Like

This offer is very bad and way too expensive.
With it I can summon 9x S1 heroes + Para (I did 14 summons in Kalavela portal and that is what I got from it). You can also bring your Klaern to 3/70 and then ascend him and max him to 4/80 instantly!

3 Likes

If nobody buys it, they may sweeten it for the next time it comes up, until people start buying it. But…I bet there are a few that will bite, no matter what.

1 Like

You guys saw today’s new offer, right?

SG be tripping if they offer basically 2 items plus some average tokens for 100$…

2 Likes

They’ve radically overestimated what “new” brings to a consumable item.

1 Like

Nice breakdown! Would love to get @BlackZed 's take on this as well. IIRC,

10x EHT = 3000 gems
1x Legendary Tome of Ascension = 8x 4AM = $40 (excluding food/iron costs which do have some value)
1x Legendary Tome of Experience = 8x Epic Tome of Experience = $64 (excluding food and iron costs which should add $10-$20 or more)

So, all in all around $130 worth of items for $100.

For some players, time is money. E.g., there’s no guarantee when you’d be able to secure all the AMs to ascend a hero. I for one, don’t like to wait years but I’m C2P so this offer is not for me, but I can see some going after this.

Your valuation of EHT is an interesting take but EHT can have high values in Kalevala or Winter summon - winter heroes still feature prominently in the top raid teams. They are also the one of the cheapest ways for F2P/C2P to get quality heroes. I’m guessing we’ll be seeing more seasonal summon portals in future so I’m not sure if we should downgrade EHTs just yet.

Also noteworthy is that Lianna’s offer or Black Friday summon costs just as much and gives 1/3rd (or less?) the AMs but 4x 10 pulls or 1x 30 pull + 1x 10 pull for same price. And you still got to add the time factor waiting for rest of AMs, farming etc.

1 Like

Here you go. :point_up:

I will look at that “yellow” offer soon. This offer is easier to analyse. Been busy.

1 Like

That cost breakdown assumes that all AM have equal value. They don’t. Even the same item can have different values to different players because only the ones you don’t already have are worth buying. You can’t place full value on the AMs that go into ascending a hero because you can’t use the AM you already have. So the monetary value should only apply to half (at most) of the value we place on AMs.

It’s really wrong to consider a 5star tome as being worth 4x 4star tome. Really. It does the job of four, but only if you use the four tomes in the stupidest way possible.

1 Like

Thanks @BlackZed! I updated my offer post.

@Mikal Couldn’t agree more with you. 1x Tome can be worth 6x Tonic because you need that many to ascend a hero. Gems can be cheaper if bought from Zynga store as well. The generalization I did is supposed to give a ballpark.

1 Like

Much of the value you place on that Tonic is that you get to choose that it’s the Tonic you get. It’s not valued at 6x the cost of one Tonic because the only time you buy the Tonic is when you already have four or five of them and just need to complete the set. The last Tonic you need is worth far more to you than the first one you get.

1 Like

The last Tonic you need is worth far more to you than the first one you get.

Emotionally yes. Rationally not so much. The dollar cost of one tonic is the cost of one tonic - no matter if it’s your 1st or 6th or 100th - SG charges the same.

I get your viewpoint but if we start going down that rabbit hole, we can never assign any rational value to anything. Peace out!

3 Likes

Master Trainer Offer ($9.99)

Items Value
4x 3* Master Trainers -
5x 2* Master Trainers -
6x 1* Master Trainers -
Total $10.00

Synopsis If you want to spend money on these, then this $10 Master Trainer offer seems to be on par with Feel The Power’s $5 offer while both are significantly better than the $30 Master Trainer offer. However you can also obtain them practically for free along with Legendary pulls in Feel The Might or Tier 5 in Court Of Roses

Appeared On: [July 14, 2022], [August 30, 2022], [October 5, 2022], [November 16, 2022], [December 7, 2022], [December 29, 2022], [January 15, 2023], [February 1, 2023], [March 1, 2023], [April 6, 2023], [June 1, 2023], [June 19, 2023], [August 8, 2023], [September 1, 2023], [September 26, 2023], [October 20, 2023], [November 14, 2023], [December 12, 2023], [January 4, 2024], [February 22, 2024], [March 6, 2024]

Other valuations

2 Likes

Challenge Offers

[July 14, 2022]

Day 1
Tier 1
Items Value
3000x Gems $15.00
100x Challenge Coins $13.00
10x WE Flasks $5.00
Total $33.00
Tier 2
Items Value
200x Gems $1.00
Total $1.00

Synopsis Tier 1 is a plus value offer if you consider the flasks. Tier 2 is standard offer for gems and is a fair value one as get dollar per dollar.


Day 2
Items Value
300x Gems $1.50
10x Challenge Coins $1.30
Total $2.80

Synopsis A subpar offer as you get less game dollars per real dollar.


Day 3
Items Value
400x Gems $2.00
15x Challenge Coins $1.95
Total $3.95

Synopsis A slight subpar offer as you get less game dollars per real dollar.


Day 4
Items Value
3000x Gems $15.00
100x Challenge Coins $13.00
5x WE Flasks $2.50
Total $30.50

Synopsis A slightly plus value offer considering the flasks.

Other valuations
1 Like

:joy::rofl::joy::rofl: I believe there is. Done for Atlantis. A long time ago. Will get to it.

For starters : 200gems for us$0.99 is one of the better deals. 48% discount. I buy that to load up on gems slowly.

2 Likes

Court of Roses

Tier 1

Items Value
200x Gems $1.00
Total $1.00

Synopsis A fair value offer as you get dollar for dollar in game value.

Tier 2

Items Value
300x Gems $1.50
1x WE Flasks $0.50
Total $2.00

Synopsis A fair value offer as you get dollar for dollar in game value.

Tier 3

Items Value
300x Gems $1.50
30x Loot Tickets $1.50
1x WE Flasks $0.50
Total $3.50

Synopsis A plus value offer if you consider the WE flask, otherwise a fair value offer.

Tier 4

Items Value
40x Challenge Coins $5.20
Total $5.20

Synopsis A plus value offer even without the battle items (and those are some of the most expensive ones to farm/produce). This is one of the best places to stock up on Challenge coins.

Tier 5

Items Value
500x Gems $2.50
150x Dunes Coins $2.25
Master Trainers -
Total $4.75

Synopsis We currently don’t have enough data to value master trainers. Without them, this is a slightly subpar offer.

Other valuations

Appeared On: [July 15, 2022], [July 31, 2022], [August 21, 2022], [September 4, 2022], [September 29, 2022], [October 27, 2022], [November 24, 2022], [December 22, 2022], [January 20, 2023], [February 18, 2023], [March 18, 2023], [April 16, 2023] , [May 13, 2023], [June 9, 2023], [June 16, 2023], [July 8, 2023], [August 4, 2023], [August 31, 2023], [September 28, 2023], [October 26, 2023], [November 24, 2023], [December 16, 2023], [January 27, 2024], [February 6, 2024], [March 24, 2024]
2 Likes

Choose Your Limit Break

Items Value
2x Partial Aether Set -
Total $0.00

* Aether Set = 1x 5*, (5 or 6)x 4*, 10x 3* aethers

Buying all 5x

Items Value
10x Aether Set $50.00
5x Extra AE III Bonus!
Total $50.00

Synopsis This offer lacks complete aether sets in the same color. However, if you consider the total aethers, you’re getting 2 sets worth of aethers, totaling $10 - which makes this a fair value offer. If you bought all 5, you’ll end up with 2x complete aether sets in every color and 5 AEIII to spare. The bite size nature allows you to mix-n-match AEIII which is handy.

Other valuations

Appeared On: [July 16, 2022], [August 19, 2022], [September 7, 2022], [September 26, 2022], [November 21, 2022], [December 8, 2022], [December 25, 2022], [February 26, 2023], [March 13, 2023], [March 27, 2023], [April 22, 2023], [May 6, 2023], [June 3, 2023], [June 23, 2023], [July 15, 2023], [August 9, 2023], [September 9, 2023], [October 1, 2023] , [October 25, 2023], [November 16, 2023], [December 11, 2023], [January 3, 2024], [January 24, 2024], [February 11, 2024], [February 26, 2024], [March 3, 2024], [March 25, 2024]
3 Likes

Tournament Offer ($9.99)

:money_mouth_face: Value Breakdown

[July 17, 2022], [August 28, 2022], [September 18, 2022], [October 30, 2022], [November 20, 2022], [December 10, 2022], [January 22, 2023], [February 12, 2023], [March 5, 2023], [March 26, 2023], [April 16, 2023], [May 7, 2023], [June 18, 2023], [July 9, 2023], [July 30, 2023], [August 21, 2023], [September 10, 2023], [October 1, 2023], [October 22, 2023], [November 12, 2023], [December 3, 2023], [December 24, 2023], [January 14, 2024], [March 18, 2024]

image

2 Likes

Forgotten Treasures of Ice


Pic Credit @KILGORE

Tier 1

Items Value
200x Gems $1.00
30x Loot Tickets $1.50
3x WE Flasks $1.50
Total $4.00

Synopsis A plus value offer including the flasks, tickets, subpar otherwise.

Tier 2

Items Value
300x Gems $1.50
4x EHT $5.20
4x ETT $3.20
250K Food $0.25
Total $10.15

Synopsis A plus value offer even discounting the food/ham.

Tier 3

Items Value
600x Gems $3.00
500x Dunes Coins $7.50
50x Challenge Coins $7.50
Total $18.00

Synopsis A plus value offer as you get more game dollars per real dollar. The price per pull is $1 with this offer, and you get gems to spare. Or if you use gems for pulls, the price per pull comes down to $0.83.

Tier 4

Items Value
1200x Gems $6.00
2x 4AM $10.00
1.5M Food $1.50
Total $17.50

Synopsis Even with the food bundles, the offer is subpar because you get less game dollars per real dollar; however, you get Damascus Blade and a Tome of Tactics together, and this is one of the few places where you can get them together. Still, you have to get past the paywall for the first three offers, which makes it more expensive.

Tier 5

Items Value
1800x Gems $9.00
2x Epic Tome of Emblems $20.00*
3x Epic Tome of Ascension -
5x 3* Trainers -
Total -

* Tentative value as we gather more data.

Synopsis This one is hard to assess as there isn’t enough data to value the tomes & trainers yet. The gem value is clearly not worth it and rest of the items only help in speed levelling heroes/troops.

Appeared On: [July 17, 2022], [September 17, 2022], [October 16, 2022], [November 4, 2022], [November 22, 2022], [December 11, 2022], [December 26, 2022], [January 18, 2023], [February 4, 2023], [February 27, 2023], [March 15, 2023], [April 4, 2023], [April 18, 2023], [May 9, 2023], [May 18, 2023], [May 31, 2023], [June 16, 2023], [July 9, 2023], [August 2, 2023], [August 27, 2023], [October 15, 2023], [November 4, 2023], [December 1, 2023], [December 26, 2023], [January 7, 2024], [February 28, 2024], [March 7, 2024]

Other valuations

3 Likes

Would be nice to get a cleared copy of FToI even if you have to steal it from elsewhere.

1 Like

@Mikal click on the Value Breakdown link - it has a cleared copy and that topic also has it in lots of other currencies

1 Like