I have to agree with @H0fm4nN regarding the issue with titans. I agree that some alliances may want to use it for higher titans, but the whole point of hitting titans is teamwork and some alliances may try to compulsively make people buy VIP. I have bought one significant package from this game which was the Valentine’s day offer, I personally believe that more offers like that would be more beneficial for SG than the VIP which already gives plenty of additional goodies to the buyer.
Finally I will add that as a co-leader of an alliance I can see myself choosing to buy VIP once I am off a college student’s budget. In other words I feel college students would likely be more incentivized by an offer similar to the Valentine’s day offer and might consider VIP later even as it stands now and with no need to risk an over balance on titans. I would still like to see this discussion had, but overall I think it needs refinement before I can make a decision about my personal vote.
Good luck to everyone on the game.