To select players for my alliance I review their roster. Typically I am interested in their 5* and 4* heroes, war teams, mana troops and profile page (highest titan dmg, raid wins, confirm current alliance).
In the past players would take screenshots and post those in our public community chat (over a 1000 people in there). After a few issues with screenshots being abused for fake accountselling, and players getting suspended by SG for suspected account selling, we changed our procedure. Screenshots will now be removed from public chat and only shared via direct msg.
Considering pretty much every top 200 alliance a minimum standard that requires a roster check I think the screenshots shouldn’t be nescerry.
So let’s remove the screenshots all together and lower the risk of screenshots being abused, while at the same time make vetting / recruiting easier.
My proposal. If a player wants to be considered for an alliance he could click on the leader of that alliance and a popup will come up to share his roster.
The leader of this alliance will be notified (ingame msg) and will be able to see the player roster in a different lay-out than ussual ( to prevent actual account screenshots from spreading). For extra security a watermark could be applied to this type of roster view.