The perception of it is common knowledge. Everyone talks about the A+ curse. The reality is different than perception.
Put on that SG conspirast hat that you like to don so often. You believe the tiles are rigged, so that people get frustrated and pay more. Does it make sense to frustrate less people, the ones who get A or A+, or to frustrate more people, the ones who get B and C?
Not really. I like to defend logic and common sense. A losing battle these days
No way, someone clearly rigged the counting. Probably the same people who have been counting votes recently. You get more chance of good loot the higher the loot tier? And that is backed up by thousands of pieces of tracked data? Preposterous!
So based on those tracked pieces of data that @Sarah2 shared… Assuming 5% chance of a 4* mat at A+, and 2.83% chance of a 4* mat at C (these won’t be exact, but in the ball park given its a fair sample that was used).
What is the chance that the person who scored an A+ in the alliance gets a 4* mat? Let’s say 20% (4 rolls * 5% - it is not that simple, but trying to simplify for the sake of demonstrating a point)
Let’s say there are 15 people who hit C tier. What is the chances of them getting a 4* mat? 15 * 2.83% * 4 (again, simplifying).
So on average every 5th titan the A+ person gets a 4* mat. But every titan 1.7 C people get a 4* mat. Does that mean it is 8-9 times more likely that you get a 4* mat at C tier? Should everyone aim to hit C tier? No!- but cumulatively the odds are much higher that you will get more people getting 4* mats at C rather than A+. Hence, the perception that the reward is better.
Don’t say everyone when not everyone agrees with you. I don’t need to try, I get A+ loot 9 times out of 10. I’ve averaged 2 4* materials from 8-12* titans, (mostly 10*) per month for about the last year with screenshots as proof. I think the record was 5 4* material one month but only because one of them had 3 4*.
Lately 8-9 as we are down to 18 members now. Lost so many long time friends after Telly - Vela nerfs… If we want we can kill 10 also but as that will put stress on alliance we are just chilling with 8 and 9’s lately.
But this upcoming Mystic Titan makes it really weird for alliances like us. We will all see what will happen…
So titan level/tier does make a huge difference. You hitting A+ at (say) a 9* titan is like someone hitting C at a 12* titan.
I generally hit B or C on 14* titans (resources going into building HA 10, plus I don’t have the best titan teams, plus I’m probably not that good at titans anyway) and on average walk away with a 4* mat every 1-2 weeks. If you were able to join an alliance that hits 14* titans you would be getting much better loot at C level than you currently do with A+.
Maybe you fail to see my reason of commenting to this thread. I am not saying Titan drop less loot. I am saying there maybe an in-balance within A+ , A loot compared to B loot. Many other user as you can see claim the same.
And you also mention that with B and C you average 1 3 ascension mat every 1-2 week
Yes, I also explained above why more people at C and B get the 4* mats. But at the same time, you get more chance of 4* mats at A+.
I have been at A+ less times, but I have a higher percentage of 4* mat drops from A+ than I have from C or B. And so I try to get as high as I can every single time, because I know my chances of good loot is better. Every time I see a 3* mat at C loot I curse myself because there is a chance it would have been a 4* instead if I was one tier higher
yes i think its make sense when u say thats depend on how many stars…but i try from titan 10* until 14*…me and my friend in my alliance feel a same…C or B rank get more easy find 4* ascending material thans rank A or A+