Good evening this just happen while I was playing
They keep saying it can’t happen but I have to say I wonder if there is a glitch somehow that allows it.
I’ve read several times that attacks started BEFORE you came online can FINISH while you’re online and make it look like an online attack, when technically it’s not.
One of those imponderables…
Yes that very well be true in some cases but I was in alliance chat went to edit heros and up pops that screen shot. Ylthings Thar make you go HMMMM
How long had you been online at that point? Hmmm, indeed!
About a half hour or so not any less
Well that’s disappointing! I’d definitely report it to game support (with the detail of how long you’d been online)…
Consider too that you can be online but depending on your connection you can get offline hiccups.
Example: I was having a horrible connection, some of my messages would show up in my chat and then disappear a couple seconds after. The game was having trouble connecting. When it did, with it came a hit. The game was technically open and “online”, but for that time it couldn’t communicate with the server, so technically I was offline.
That’s hard to see because it only goes to the “connecting” screen after it fails to connect for a while.
Another example is when the game was having server issues, me and a bunch of people were talking in chat just fine, even global. But raids were not working at all. You can be connected to the chat and actually use it, but have trouble to connect with the “raid part” and be technically offline.
If it were possible to actually raid some online, there wouldn’t be that “this person is online and can’t be attacked” window and you would have a lot more of that happening. Those are just hiccups and bad connections.
Thank you all I will continue to monitor if it happens again then I will send a bug fix report, not that raiding matters to me much anymore, only raiding now to fill hero chests. Have a great day
Also consider that there are places you can hang out in the game where you won’t receive notices. Alliance chat is one of them. Think of the notification you get when your titan dies. It will only pop up when you are on your base screen, and the world map screen. (I don’t think it will show when you are on a map for a specific province…)
I logged in and fiddled around doing various things in game and then the raid notification popped up: first thought, what the duck; second thought, oh it’s dated from 7 minutes ago from before I had logged in.
Some delay in the system apparently too.
I have had this happen as well. Log in, comment in the alliance chat, come out and find a notice waiting for me. But like you, it was timed as 10 minutes before and I had only been on for about 5.
Its because you’re in the top 100.
Just so you’re aware…when this thread was created it was way back in 2017; and I think at that time you couldn’t be raided whilst online at all.
I have been on line all day from early morning to currently I have had 4different raids happen while being on line I have close all screen savers off and screen has always been on. I am always do some sort of building and never letting the game go off line know that this has happened before. I last month had the same problem losing over 300 in raid points this time I have lost about 150 raid points. Please fix this bug as I am always spending money on this game as I enjoy it but this is turning me off the game rule states if online you can not be raided. Well I fine that is is not true. Please fix the problem. Thanks
Hi @Raceman, and welcome to the forum! I’m not a developer, so I don’t know their thinking exactly. But they seem to not want people to be able to avoid getting raided indefinitely by simply keeping the game open.
I often run the game in one window in my phone and something else–like the forum–in another. In my experience, if I’m not actively clicking on something in game every so often, it will decide that I’m inactive and allow raids.
You say you were online all day, but were you active? If you ever got the “are you still there?” Popup, then you were kicked offline.
Also, top 100 players can be revenged while they are online.
It’s happened to me several times.
Just happened to me also- was raided while raiding. After winning my battle, my raid arena dropped and my loot all got zero’d. I had fought three raids consecutively so there is no way someone started raiding me before I was online.
Hi and thanks
Just letting you know this is still happening while I and rearranging my troops so I am still getting raided while inline I revenges the person and got the same amount back but but that is not the point this seems to be happening most of the time while I am doing other things like raiding other or fighting Titans so can not come back and say I am inactive
Please find pic of the raid and person that did it