Pirates vs Halloween. Where would you summon?

I would like Peters and I would like Victor.

Peters is more likely being 4* than Victor at 5*. However the real reason to pull for me is Kingston. That is until I saw this.

If I have to wait until December for him to be fixed, that makes me angry. I still want him for when he is fixed, but my anger is diminishing my desire to spend any money.

I think I will save my EHT for December and maybe only pull 1-2 times in each event just to open the door for a miracle.