[Master] Trading Between Players - Please add your comments & ideas here!

Many in the forum have made posts requesting the feature to trade items between players. This thread has collected the posts of the requests and ideas players have had regarding this idea. Please continue to add your thoughts on this subject here!

Here’s an excerpt from the Ask Me Anything with Tim, the Lead Designer , written up by myself.

And another excerpt from the list of things Small Giant is considering for future development:

Trade EVERYTHING in Alliances!
Alliance item donation
Tradeing/Shareing with people
Proposal - Trading system
Idea for game
Exchange of heroes and materials between alliance members
Possibility to give a Hero
Sharing resource between member of Alliance
A Gift system!
Inter-alliance trade with a 45 day lock on remaining in your respective alliance
Hero trading
Shortlist of Frequent Requests (Ruled Out & Considering - Please Read Before Posting!)
Guild Vaults
Что если создать рынок?
:boom: SG year 2019 possible feature releases! WOW! Thoughts and Inputs - update added
How to Contact Support (Version 31 Onwards)
Help With Forum Issues Available Here! - old
Ascend items
SGG : Instead of trading give us a hero market. It will be a win win
Things we would like to see in the game
Alliance Improvement Ideas
Cuadrilatero de pruebas para Alianzas
Secret Santa for Alliances
Some suggestions in game
Idea: *Exchange/Trades*
Рынок в игре
Moeda de troca
Trading characters
Exchange heroes
Sharing creature
Suggestion - regarding Alliance(s)
Purely donation of heroes to alliance members
Purely donation of heroes to alliance members
Alliance members being able to share resources and heroes
Trade System
Alliance Gifts for Player Birthdays
One MarketPlace
Trying to decide if I want to keep playing
Change Heroes between members of an alliance
A Paid Trade System
Share hero as a reward for clan
Sharing loot/ascension items
Scambio di eroi,solamente per i membri della stessa alleanza
Trading Post Within Alliane
Trade of items, especially ascension items!
Trading within the alliance
Inventory items
Proposal - Trading
Exchange system
Exchange Itens
Idea in improving the game
Strong alliances
Hero trade?
Alliance trading
Trade Options
Trading materials and ingredients
Gift to team members
Would like to see a trade heros system
iD#03 - a New!? Donate / Trade system
Trading hero's within
Exchange warriors and resources
Support for the Allies
Помощь друзьям
Better resources for heroes from 3 * to 5 *
Exchange of heroes between players
Trade in loot
Selling Overstock Resources
Trading and Buying
Market place
Second Builder / Building Wait Times - Please add your ideas and comments here!
Exchanging heros among alliance members
Swapping Heroes
New Features for Alliances
Ask Me Anything with Small Giant's Lead Designer - a write up by Coppersky- Nov 2017
Trade Day?
Trading farmable items
Gifting to others
Helping alliance members
Item Trade among Players
No Tome of Tactics
Exchange tickets
HEROES EXCHANGE between Alliance Members
Gifts to other players of the team
Gifts to other players of the team
Trading Heroes in alliances
Trade crafting items
Trade crafting items
Trading with alliance members and adding friends
Alliance ShopTrade
Trading with alliance members and adding friends
Alliance ShopTrade
Ascension materials or lack there of
Just the place for a Snark! I have said it once
Trading your unwanted heroes for a gem fee
Alliance perks
Trading of heroes
Trading items and resources within Alliance!?
Traiding resources with alliance members
Trading Post within an alliance
Trading Post within an alliance
Рынок в игре
A new alliance feature to improve the game by a great deal – Alliance Fortress/Stronghold and New Alliance Buildings
Allowing players to trade heroes
Are you ever going to open a trade system
In house/alliance trading
Alliance Communication Features - Please add your comments & ideas here!
Swapping assention items only between members in your alliance
Swapping players on Alliance teams
What's wrong with trading?
Feature in comming releases?
What is the harm in trading items?
Trading of ascension materials and ingredients
Allow alliance members to trade
Allow alliance members to trade
Trade ins sell items/materials
Help A Brotha Out
Team market
Trading items?!?
How about an Alliance Swap Coin
Replace heroes between aliance members
Amazing Idea!
Rare item disbursement seems skewed
Sharing resources
Sharing with new players – Is there a way to gift items to my team as the alliance leader?
The bastion has no role, it is present by a simple photo. why don’t you give it a role?
Trading in alliances
Trading or selling items
Trading fighters within an alliance
Donations amongst one’s alliance
Help With Forum Issues Available Here! - old
New building: university
Trades in the game? Just a suggestion
Ideas ideas
Suggestion: Borrow A Hero
Global Exchange Merket
Please let us trade
Daily friends gift
Finding compasses
So how can TRADING effect the Developers income?
Trading among alliance members
Trading among alliance members
So how can TRADING effect the Developers income?
Practice Battles or Raids Against Teammates in Alliance [MASTER]
To Developers
Alliance missions
Trade quest loot
Suggestions for the convenience and development of the game
Exchange of objects
Suggestion to create market-places for materials within the framework of alliances
I'm Quitting over Fine Gloves
Hero Trading amongst alliance members
A couple of ideas for the Devs
Request from my team members
RSS Sharing
Market trading
Donations in Clans
Introduce trading to the game
Resources between alliance members
Trading between players
Alliance bank
Intra alliance trading -tradepost
A Few Thoughts on the Game...(minor)
Guild Armory Feature
Inner Alliance Trading / communication
Gifting Members
Alliance Market for us!
An idea about TRADING heroes and DUPLICATE heroes
Send gifts to friends in alliance group
Ascension items for trade
Trade of heros within alliance members
Ideas for this game
Trading Assention item in own teams
Gift of acesension materials to Alliance members
My ideea would be for X-mas presents
About trading
Vote suggestion
Suggestion for swaping heroes
Vote suggestion
Trade option?
Is there space for a in game market?
Is there space for a in game market?
Heroes exchanging among alliance mates
Trading good/items within ALLIANCE members
Troca entre membros da aliança
Three ideas
Player trading?
Trade in alliance option
Trade Suggestion
Limited/ Restricted Trading within Alliances
Proposal: implement the game with the exchange of heroes within the Guild
Can we please make hero’s tradable
:test_tube: The Beta Beat (v23) [NOW RELEASED] – Sharing the Big Picture on What's Going on in Beta: Stronghold 22/23 & Alchemy Lab, New Challenge Event Heroes, New Knights of Avalon & Pirates of Corellia Challenge Events, Costumes, November/December HOTM
Item and resource trading
Item and resource trading
The game turned into a "swamp" AKA Yet another complaint thread. Please ignore
Feature Request: Alliance members trading resources
Feature Request: Alliance members trading resources
Allow Gifting Heroes to Alliance Member Once per Month, so P2P Players Can Help Out F2P Players
Acquiring Ascension items and sharing in the alliance ECT
Helden bei kleineren allianz mitgliedern abstellen
Trade idea
Trading items
Trading between established alliance members
Exchange items
Alliance trading post
Alchemy building to craft ascension items
Trading unused players to members of the same alliance
Sharing within Alliance
Ascension Items Exchange
In Alliance trading
Feature request: Gifting for alliance leaders
Trade Opportunities
Hope someday will allows transfer items
Trading Heroes for war
Trading between alliance members
10 things SG should do to keep players happy
Leaders privilege
Hero exchange
Decent idea for Hero trading?
Creating a "Flea Market" to trade amoungst ALLIANCE MEMBERS
Dealing items amongst alliance
Trading of items within alliances
Trading of items within alliances
Exchange of hereos amongst alliance members
Inter-alliance sharing
Proposals from some players
Mideaval neighborhood trade market
Create new
Materials exchange
Materials exchange
Two for one hero trading?
Hero Trading Ideas
Hero and material trading mode

465 posts were merged into an existing topic: [KNOWN ISSUE] Continuing Event Battle with Gems (12/July) STATUS: Android Update Out - iOS Coming Soon

A post was split to a new topic: Spins for daily rewards

A post was split to a new topic: Passing Province 9-7

2 posts were split to a new topic: Hero Color Change?

A post was split to a new topic: Why so many 1-2* Troops?

831 posts were merged into an existing topic: [SOLVED] Continuing Event Battle with Gems (12/July) STATUS: Android & iOS Update Out

Is this a possible thing in the near future?

I’m against that only because can be exploitable and can lead to an unbalanced game!!!


Are there some limited trade options that wont imbalance the game? I’m interested in those… :wink:


Besides cash for gems? :wink:


Not sure if this has been suggested, I haven’t been following. What about trading 2 for 1. Say I need darts and an alliance member needs tonics. I trade two of my darts and he gets one tonic, and he trades two of his tonics and I get one dart. I’m happy, he’s happy, and SmallGiant is happy because the double up ascension materials are off the board.


I would love to trade players between my alliance. I have multiples of players they want and they have players I want. Is trading heros going to be an option and not just resources?


More thought would be 400 gems to trade a hero of equal value, if you have a player of the month its 800 and 2 five star players you would trade.


Personally, i feel that trading items/heros among Alliance members in no way should break the game, so long as SG put limitations on the parameters of trading. Some examples would be, they must be in the alliance minimum of 2-3 weeks/a month before they can trade, maximum 1 trade a week/biweekly/month, only trade items of equal value(4* ascension item for a 4* ascension item and 3* for 3*, etc.), also, pay 100/200 gems to complete the trade, etc.

I see no reason why this wouldn’t work… so long as we pay a small price and it makes us happy.


Excatly, we all pay to get our players and a big summon costs 30 dollars for one try. So why not let the players pay a slightly higher price knowing they will get what they want. 1 hero one price. The makers will still profit off of this and the gamers will be more than happy. A cap would have to be neccessary though.


My idea of trading would be something like what they did to Pokémon Go. You pay game resources (in this case, it would be gems) for the trade to be possible. And in the case of this game, I’d say you have to trade things of equal value, like a 5* hero for a 5* hero, a 4* ascension mat for another 4* ascension mat and so on.


Cookie Settings