Idea: Ability to watch war fights in progress [MASTER]

Tidying things up and combining threads. This thread is for the discussion of being able to view a teammate’s battle either in progress, or after it happens. Please contintinue to add your thoughts to the discussion!

Also, a quick reminder to do a brief search to see if your idea is already posted. It is more effective to have a single discussion about a topic, and to vote on a single thread instead of many. (There were 20 votes for this idea that got split over multiple threads)

Below are previous threads on this topic, and a few of the posts that stand out in those conversations.

Ability to watch War fights
Alliance wars tweak
Viewing a war attack
AW Spectator Mode
Spectator mode for AW
Raid Playback (and Alliance War spectating)
Spectator mode in AW
A real spectator mode
War chat / war spectator
War watching system
Want to be able to Watch the fight when my teammates fight in a war

Spectator mode in AW
A real spectator mode
Ideas and imporvment for the game to make more fun
A True 'Spectator' Mode
Implement role of observing a fight in Alliance wars
Alliance war live view feature-ittifak savaşını canlı izleme özelliği
Alliance war live view feature-ittifak savaşını canlı izleme özelliği
War spectator view
Observation button during war
Forum Interviews: An Audience with@ScottySG 🎙️
Viewing battles
War match live view
Truly spectator (watching) feature in wars
Guild wars - Spectator mode
Create the Ability to Watch War Battles
Alliance wars tweak
Viewing a war attack
Raid Playback (and Alliance War spectating)
Ability to watch War fights
AW Spectator Mode
Spectator mode for AW
War chat / war spectator
Want to be able to Watch the fight when my teammates fight in a war
War watching system
View attacks in war
Add Chatting Among War Teams
Spectating war attacks
Live War Viewing (Or at least replays)
First person veiwing in AW
Alliance Wars 'spectator mode'
Alliance Wars 'spectator mode'
Wanted: new spectator mode in AW
Ver la guerra de un compañero
Let see alliance attacks
War Battle View Mode
Added spectator mode in the war
War is fun to watch, spectator improvements?
Spectator Mode during War
During the war, watch the battles of his alliance
War battle viewing
Playback battles
Spec Alliance Member Live In War Attack
"Watch battle" option inwar/titans
Ability to watch raids live
Ability to watch raids live
We want a replay: a possibility of see how an oppponent attack you!
Be able to watch Alliance war attacks
Viewing fellow ALLIANCE members wars
As a user, I want to have the ability to view battles real-time in wars
Spectating war battles and practice fights
Game suggestions - Sir Tag
Spectator Option
Can we get a new function?
War and Titan chat subgroups
PROPOSAL - Replays for War Battles
Watch other battles during war
Watch other battles during war
Couple of Suggestions for improvement of the game
Helden bei kleineren allianz mitgliedern abstellen
Full interaction of the alliance in the war
Any chance of Spectator Mode during war?
Added spectator mode in the war
SOS SG! Suggestions to improve the game
10 things SG should do to keep players happy
Watching alliance war battles
Ability to watch battles in progress on the battlefield
Adding in the ability to spectate a match
Proposals from some players
PvsP live viewing
War video chat
Give us the ability to view war attacks
Give us the ability to view war attacks
Alliance Challenges
Spectator mode a teammates match in AW
I want to watch the batteles in alliance wars
I want to watch the batteles in alliance wars
Visualization of battles in war
War 2.0: Summary of Improvements
Want to be able to Watch the fight when my teammates fight in a war
Spectator mode for alliance wars

Yes, this idea was mentioned multiple times. I did that also.

It can be a recording or a live streaming. Perhaps a recording that can be viewed later is easier and more helpful. Team can review battles and do some analyzes. On the other hand, life streaming doesn’t require large server side storage.

3 Likes

I was pondering on this. Some technical thoughts.

A battle is a step-by-step process. A log of a battle should be not more than a chess game script: Initial information includes Heroes and troops stats for both parties (10 heroes and 10 troops) and initial board (35 integers). For a full log of a step we need a list of matched and generated tiles and damage they inflicted. Overall it shouldn’t exceed 50K Byte of information per turn.

Raid is not very fast running process, so sending this amount of data asynchronously after each turn should not be a big deal. Transfer can be synchronized at the end of a raid, when the raid results are sent to server.

Higher volume of data can be for sending combos, but for the sake of saving bandwidth all combos could be reduced to sending just a final state of a board. I’m not sure this will save a lot of traffic, though.

From a server it can be broadcast to subscribers, if any of them connected to view the battle.

4 Likes

I’m not sure if someone else suggested this yet, I couldn’t find it but…

It was be awesome if members of an alliance could actually see the attacks as they’re taking place in the same way that the attacking player sees them.

Whenever another player makes an attack we just see that there is a battle. Everyone has to wait until the battle is over to see the end result. Wars would be so much more exciting if we could actually see the live battle taking place. Replays could also be a good idea, also when defending against raids.

This could also help players to learn different strategies, see where their defenses fail, and make it more like a live sporting event.

Cheers,

DB

3 Likes

I think Wars could be more interesting if you could view war attacks. It could be a learning tool to improve attacks. Also give players something to do while looking at the battlefield when you’re waiting on new attacks. All you can see is someone being attacked and just wondering what is going on. Just an idea…

I think that this idea will bring more transfer, what, I suppose, isn’t good solution. I like this game because I have limited Internet monthly and E&P really takes very samll amount of transfer. This idea will definitely grow up a transfer… :frowning:

It would be great to see the fight we were the victim to see how our defense was shot in order to improve it.
And it wiuld be great to see teammate fight mostly when there is suspens in the war!

1 Like

How hard would it be to add a ‘spectator mode’ in the alliance war so players could observe their fellow alliance members attacks, and especially the opponents attacking their own defence teams.

Another deeper level to this would be, to be able to ‘playback’ the attacks. players would learn a lot from their fellow members and their opponents.

Thoughts?

2 Likes

It would be pretty neat to watch other players. Maybe we could even watch alliancemates raiding live.

For the technical implementation, it all depends on how the devs currently run raids. If it’s completely run on the server, it should be easy to implement. If some or all is handled by the client, then they will probably need to move that, which can take some time and resources on the devs. But live, sure, it’s probably feasible.

But saving battles would probably require the devs to establish a whole new database. That’s a lot of information to store compared to what they already store for profiles. Alternatively, they could store those replay files on the client… It wouldn’t work if you played on multiple devices or cleared your app data, but it might make more sense for a small company to do this. Possible, but would have to be carefully thought out by devs.

here is a topic for discussing this idea:

@Rook @Kerridoc could you, please, handle this thread as a duplicate?

1 Like

Hi, I’d like to have a spectator Opportunity to see in real-time how a fight is fought within the AW. Watching my own Team as well as the ones of my Alliance Members. Just like peeking over the shoulder of my Alliance Member, or watching my own hero’s how they defend.

What do you think, is this possible?
People of the small giant Team, could you do this?

Greetings from Germany
Top

@Kerridoc

20 characters

Want!!!

20 characters

I’m sure this is not the case with all alliances, but ours is open to players with 4K teams all the way down to the low1k range and we frequently talk back and forth about strategy and the like. This got me thinking, it would be nice if we could watch replays of a titan hit or war hit to see what team structure was used and how it worked out for any level, but especially for those participating in their first few wars or titan battle.

I’m not sure how feasible this is, but it would be fun.

I think it would be amazing to at the least be able to watch the replay of war attacks made against our team. I don’t know how well this would be received or if it would be something used often.

I wouldn’t show the opponents board moves or tiles at all but maybe show all heroes health and mana? I’m curious to know say how does my Gormek tank hold up compared to Wilbur. Think it would be sweet.

I’m always interested to see what my fellow members play like in Wars, it would be a good way to help others and to see what move they make and where they are going right and wrong.

Okay, so I go to U tube and watch real time battles frequently so this concept is not so much impossible. Personally, I would like to have the see/no see option, but it should probably be live stream only. I really see no need to watch myself get slaughtered repeatedly by the same opponents. However, it might be sweet if I were to beat anchor or avicicious. Is anchor still playing even?

I came on the forum for this exact reason. I want to be able to see war battles as they are happening. It would add more interest and keep people on beyond when they are done with their flags.

----> He have a good idea like yours <----

1 Like

Would be cool if we were able to watch our alliance members live as they battle during War.

We’re already watching from the sidelines, let us have the option to watch the actual match!

Cookie Settings