Scarlett. Not only she is too similar to darkshade with sigrunn face, but the gold and red make her look cheap. They should use a darker golden tone and less vibrant or two tone gold with darker golden tone on the outside and lighter tone on the inside like high end mmorpg art to make them look more professional and elegant. And of course pick another red please.
Otoh, I quite like darkshade overall appearence, simple yet nicely done.