for me its not about the event is for whales issue, it’s the loot is out of whack.
First the alliance loot…
not enough tiers. PERIOD
NO incentive for alliances to really work together.
So this event is a single player event AGAIN. It is only in the disguise of a alliance based event.
Now the individual awards…
ok so its not that hard for someone who has been playing regularly for a year or less to get top 10% or even 5% and in some small percentage of cases top 1% so the % based awards here actually seem imho to work.
Its the fact that in most cases imho, if you are top 5% for a single attack you are most likely going to be top 5% for total attack. the rewards overlap and i think are identical. The rewards fro single attack and total attack should be unique to each other with total attack giving the best rewards overall between the two.
The battle items award in all 3 divisions should be massively increased in fact only tornadoes, hurricanes, scrolls, dragon and titan banners etc etc should be given out, no aces or arrows or minor healing pits etc so 4/5* battle items mostly, I would say the lowest tier should get at least 10 battle items.
The fact we are being forced to use more and more hunter’s lodge items versus the cost of them should also be addressed, make titan parts drop more or reduce costs. Also revamp some of the less used items
As I have played this event my opinion changed from “i don’t think i care for it” to “OK its not as bad as I thought” But with several other events I would like to see a revamp of the rewards system.
As stated before I would prefer the alliance rewards to have many many more tiers and possibly be just a damage based goal, such a 1 mil, 2 mil etc
Battle items should be mainly 4/5* and be heavily increased in all rewards by about 5-15 fold
Unfarmable AM should be increased for alliance and total damage and left out of single attack damage
To me all reward systems should be set up to reward your spending. Summoning heroes is not enough to succeed in events. It is one part of it. You also need unfarmable mats, battle items and resources. SO say at 10% tier it should reward you with items that help you push for 5% tier next time. so increase flasks, increase higher battle items, increase iron/food bundles increase 4* CM massively and increase unfarmable AM a touch