I know C. Boldtusk in the pic isn’t maxed yet but here’s the thing: I’ve tried feeding N. Brienne to maxed C. Brienne with level 6 special. She only gets 25% chance of leveling her special up.
Shouldn’t the chances be 100% like when you feed a hero to the same hero? I don’t know but it seems like a bug to me
There is a confusion between the hero and the costume.
In the picture you are trying to feed COSTUMED BOLDTUSK with only BOLDTUSK as a hero. That will give you 8% chance since you are using a 4* hero of the same color.
If you want 100% chance you have to use a copy of the COSTUME OF BOLDTUSK to feed COSTUMED BOLDTUSK.
Please notice in the same image that there are two labels. Heores and Costumes. Tap on costumes. If you have a second copy of the costume of Boldtusk use it to feed costumed boldtusk to get 100% chance.