Alliance Wars Matchmaking (Discussion & Developer Response) MASTER

Sorry but, It’s a joke?

My aliance:
27 members
Power 20th member 2550
Aliance score 79k (36k+43k)

Oponent aliance:
30 members
Power 20th member 3100
Aliance score 98k (46,5k+51,5k)

48 Likes
Alliance war changes
Alliance war info needed
WAR is NOT close to fair
Screw the Alliance wars!
War matchmaking manipulation
Alliance Wars Opt Out
Any plans to fix the WAR matching?
After new updated: Alliance War has became unbalanced & there's bugs/tricks
War matchmaking issues
Alliance War - constant mismatch
Fair wars, P2P vs F2P
War matchingis really bad
War Manipulation?
Not a fair fight. 😒 thanks for the wonderful update
Matchmaking for War
War pairing
AW war match ups
Any plans to fix the WAR matching?
Alliance war matchups
Alliance wars matching unfair
Unfair Matches in Alliance Wars
How war matching system works exactly
Aliance Wars | Matchmaking Problems.... in Kiril's name fix this already!
Alliance Wars match up
War matching
War Matching ... Total BS
Alliance war matchmaking definitely not right this time
War matchups
Alliance Wars matching needs to be fixed
War matchmaking needs to be more fair
When will fix the selection of alliances for war?
Terrible War Matchup
:broken_heart: I HATE / LOVE this game! – A Guide to Complaining, Celebrating, and Overcoming Obstacles
War and unreasonable pairing
Nice matching where is the balance of the game
Bugs matchmaking war
War matchmaking completely broken
War matches
Alliance rank in wars
Matchup Sucks
Field Aid And Arrow Barrage
Alliance MILESTONES
Another major alliance mismatch
Another major alliance mismatch
War Matchmaking-Beat a Dead Horse
Continued War Mismatch
How about a fair war matchup?
Broken war algorithm
Is this allowed or it is a cheat on system?
Alliance wars/6 team wars
Matchmaking/War Bug
Game breaking exploit. Please read, address and correct if you can
Alliance War win points on Un even Player counts
[MASTER] War mismatch - 136k vs. 108k war score (and other similar mismatches from other alliances)
[master] War opponent has more players (Uneven players on battlefield)
Is the game really P2W? or not?
Count to twenty before a mod/staff responds... (With a 354 count record with all mods only)
[master] War opponent has more players (Uneven players on battlefield)
:no_mobile_phones: Disconnected During War Attack /Titan /Network Connection Problem Caused Lost Attack, Flag, and Heroes in AW / Scored 0 Points on War Hit Due to Dropped Server Connection / Game Crashed and I lost my War Hit [MASTER]
Need help explaining Alliance War and Mismatching
3k less it's normal?
7 V 10 in war?
Как делается подбор противника на войне?
Lost war due to the extra member
We were demolished . War story
We were demolished . War story
Matchmaking on Alliance Wars so unfair
:no_mobile_phones: Disconnected During War Attack /Titan /Network Connection Problem Caused Lost Attack, Flag, and Heroes in AW / Scored 0 Points on War Hit Due to Dropped Server Connection / Game Crashed and I lost my War Hit [MASTER]
War matchmaking - question
Why We Always Matching Higher Teams
There should be an increase on level up percentages
My topic is about unfair selection in alliance wars
Full Impact Serious Bug issue
[master] War opponent has more players (Uneven players on battlefield)
Alliance wars still unfair
Alliance wars still unfair
:raised_hand: Stop Mercenaries! (In wars)
Calculation of Alliance Wars Score – what is War Matchmaking based on? Do trophies, Titan score, or alliance score count? [SPOILER: No.]
Game Forces You To Lose In Wars
War matching not right
We got trashed at war
War maching please help
War Matchups - Set those minds at ease
When you facing alliance with more people
War is a joke
Does this matchup seem right? (AW)
War disaster
When will you fix the Alliance war?
Unequal war matchups (Emparejamiento desigualdad)
War match up imbalance
War matchmaking is ridiculous
War yet again
War pairing is unfair
Allotment of teams in the war - why such disproportions?
Another horrible war matchup
War and its fairness
How this even fair?
War match?
Alliance Wars matchmaking ..not quite right

Mine
28 members. 4 below lvl 12. 1 inactive
Power 20 th member 2321
Alliance score 46283

Opponent
24 Members
20th member power 3050
Alliance score 81949

They are twice our Team Power even if we could field a full roll, this is worse than before.
This is going to force us to field a full field of 1 star

10 Likes

Good luck on that… I guess you MUST put 5 heroes now for any defense and minimum loss will be 20 points each

1 Like

We will also lose the full kill bonus of 200.
But what else can we do?

I’m trying to hold off on judging until we fight but I’m definitely concerned at the moment.

Our team: max power of any team is about 3700, and only 3 of us can field teams that strong. 5 are under 3000. As far as I know, there are only 4 maxed 5* heroes in the entire alliance. I’m one of the strongest players and I have none. Score about 104k.

Their team: they have 6 above 3700 (this is just their defense teams), 2 above 4000, and all but 1 above 3000. I saw about 28 maxed 5* on their defense teams; even their 15th ranked has one on their defense. Score about 109k.

Not expecting great things here. But maybe some of the opposing teams are inactive, maybe those high zoot teams are all the players have and their power levels fall off sharply after that, who knows? I’m keeping my fingers crossed.

5 Likes

What full kill bonus? There isn’t any bonus points for killing the whole alliance (if that is what you mean)

Why do you feel forced to field 1* heroes? what difference does that make? Why not atleast try properly, if you lose you lose. Isn’t it better to do it properly rather than doing a stupid 1* defence?

Now my match up isn’t that good either, the enemy team has almost double the alliance score (35k vs 65k). We’ll have to see how the war goes, but indeed at the first glance this seems worse than titan score.

8 Likes

Just fight with honor.

You cannot really know the outcome until at least after most players have used 3-4 attacks. You cannot know how many players on the other side have a deep bench of heroes and how many will be active during the war.

8 Likes

@petri, could you expand the criteria for the election of the participants in the wars a little?
You say that it is by the power of the heroes, the best hero of each team?
The best five?
All the heroes of each player?

By expanding our current war a little, total power of the defensive teams of our war (our alliance always has the best heroes in the defenses):
We: 74969 (27 members)
Our opponents: 92301 (30 members)

2 Likes

Not balanced at all. We have 44k they have 10k more… which is a lot, given the low numbers. We each have 27 members, all of their’s are 2k and up power. Ours are mostly 1k. You cannot tell me that our ppl have even ONE hero that is equivalent to their steongest one hero. They looked at player number and called it fair. The rest of how they ‘balanced’ the matching is not reflected in matches that I have seen, or heard about.

9 Likes

I sure hope it’s not only the top 5 Heros, because that does nothing to measure potential bench strength. It really needs to be top 30 if they are going to use that metric.

1 Like

Apparently it is only the best hero from each member that is taken into account.

Interesting. We never had such difference between the defense teams with the previous matching. I think that our defeat can be severe lol

2 Likes

Hello, we compare the Top 30 strongest Heroes of each player, when the matchmaking occurs for the Alliance Wars now. Hope this helps to clarify the change!

28 Likes

Hello Petri, you mean the top 30 heroes of all the alliance, or for each member ? I mean what happen if a member have 30 5* and the others only 2* :slight_smile:

3 Likes

top 30 heroes of each player or top 30 of the whole aliance? Because some matches are still terrible.
The right thing would be top 30 of each player (900 heroes of each alliance)

Thanks for the clarification.

The 30 best heroes of the whole alliance or the 30 best heroes of each player of the alliance?

Each player. :slight_smile:

6 Likes

But why we are facing still uneven number of players, we have also 26 vs 30. One of the notes of the update was number of players in the alliance. If is not like this than the hero rooster match will be not accurate.

1 Like

But if the balance of heros over the alliance isnt even, it will be worse than before?

1 Like

Thanks :smile:

Then it seems that they have a worse “bench”. Let’s see if we can give them a funny war.

1 Like