I apologize in advance if you have to move this post, Rook. But it seems to me that the other posts about this are more about complaining with some people posting solutions/ideas as comments instead of that being the stated topic. Anyways… My idea is this:
The last used war defense team strength should carry some weight when comparing team depth because of how difficult it can be in the second half. The titan score should also be used but weighted lightly as a comparison of offensive prowess. I think it would make things more fair (knowing that each alliance is so different that this can’t be done perfectly). Regardless, the matching is already much better in my opinion.
Oh, and keep the alliance member number as a factor. Thoughts?